Springs Bistro - West Milford

We stopped in 10 minutes before close as we had just arrived to the hotel. our waiter Troy was great! We had the meatballs for an appetizer and the Gnocchi and Malfadini for an entree! Very happy with our experience here : Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Great date spot but very expensive Food is pretty good, maybe not amazing We had some cocktails, apps, dinner and dessert and close to $400 with tip so.... Definitely a special occasion only type place

I was very skeptical having dinner here our first night because I read the reviews and they were authentic issues that happened to those clients. Based on my experience it would seem that there has been some sort of change in management or operations because we had a wonderful time here. First of all, the manager was able to adjust the seating for our party which was not an easy request. Secondly the waiter was very attentive, polite and knowledgeable. Finally, the food was delicious, my steak was perfect, the octopus was fresh and even the duck was great and that’s a hard one to nail down so two thumbs up .

We just had a dinner at Spring Bistro of Crystal Springs Resort. I didn't know this place and didn't have time to check the reviews, so I did order the dishes you cannot go wrong with, the salad and margaritas pizza (usually I'm more about fine dinning dishes .My friend ordered a pizza and the new york strip steak. The salad's price was $17 and it was oversalted, had no vegetables in it other than lettuce, baby greens (no tomatoes, cucumbers, etc. , tree croutons, and cheese. It was inedible, like it was not washed while leaving a sandy texture on my teeth. I had to send it back, but they did try to charge us anyway. My friend had a bad experience also with his $48 steak. The steak was ok but when he was enjoying the mash potato, he had some hard, rocky textured object in it. He hurt his tooth and was afraid to finish his dinner. My drink, red sangria, was watery and with no fruits in it. We are easy going, happy diners most of the time and appreciate good food and hard working personnel, which usually indicate our high tips. At such beautiful, classy place like Crystal Springs, we would never think that we had to leave the restaurant hungry, and having such bad experience. We would not recommend this place to anyone and would never dine here again!!!!!

Not sure why the reviews are so bad for this place. My girlfriends and I went on a Friday night and we had an awesome time. The service was great, food was great! Would definitely recommend. Views were beautiful. They didn’t rush us so we had plenty of time to sit and enjoy our delicious meals.