Blue Seafood Bar Restaurant - New York

Great fresh seafood. The four of us unanimously agreed the fresh seafood was spot on. The Scallop Carpaccio is absolutely creamy with a perfect blend of saltiness which against the cucumber was harmony on our mouths. We didn’t eat any cooked food(yet) and did not have a drink (yet as well). This was a night of fresh/chilled seafood (except for a cooked half lobster withbrandy ptarmigan chees and a grilled octopus) which hit the spot for us.

Went for Sunday brunch and the food was incredible. Very authentic. She got the lobster buratta and I got the grilled seafood sampler and we got a bottle of the house champagne for like $30. Our server I can’t remember her name but she was very niceand knew the whole menu front and back.

Went here for a solo date. It wasn’t particularly busy, yet service still took quite some time to get everything out. For such a small space, I had some difficulty trying to get my server’s attention. Besides that, the oysters were delicious, mycocktail was refreshing, but the bread trio was just ok. However, still an enjoyable experience and my meal was tasty enough.

This jewel in Islip is a must to go!! From the beautiful bar .. funky/classy vibe atmosphere ..genuinely caring staff to the amazing food!! We walked in to be greeted so warmly to a terrific upbeat soothing guitar player.. headed to the bar and enjoyed beautiful unique cocktails .. next we sat down and was greeted by very attentive welcoming staff.. I ate a delicious special which was Tuna with risotto.. omg!! I have never tasted something so impressively delicious!!!! We had appetizers and salads delicious but... The desserts to die for!!! We went with a group of 6 people so we tried a few.. flourless chocolate cake for not only everyone but the gluten free ppl was amazing .. brownie with ice cream yum .. bread pudding fabulous .. how many times do go somewhere and just want fresh berries and cream that was there too .. I will say even though hard to choose the must try winner... the homemade hot chocolate chip cookie with ice cream was heaven !! Can’t describe in words how amazing!! We weren’t tired and weren’t ready to end the night so we went to the outdoor space for a cigar and late night cocktail!! What a treat!! I must say it was a wonderful night and can’t wait to go back!!! Don’t miss this Jewel on Main Street in the town of Islip!!!

My husband and I had a lovely Sunday brunch great **** mary's, a dozen oysters (from 6 different locations), and the lobster benedict. I definitely recommend. And Rose is a superb server!