American Cut Steakhouse - New York

Came her for my husbands birthday. The lobster chili was very good but worth the almost 40 dollar price point? Not really. Its just 4 tiny pieces of lobster and a small amount of good bisque. The steaks were okay, nothing mind blowing. The NY strip had little hard fat pieces for some reason. Both steaks were burnt on the top so when you ate it theres a weird bitter taste in some bites. The jalapeño mashed potatoes are a literal nightmare. Its pureed potatoes that are very very goopy, really not mashes potatoes consistency, that are blended with a reduction of jalapeño skins. Its that awful green color and they taste like grass. Just spicy grass goop. The lobster mac and cheese was the only redeeming factor. I actually enjoyed it but again not something to write home about. We literally couldn’t finish the food and just asked for the check to leave. I got a cocktail (forgot the name of) and my husband got a beer, both were dine. Service was fine. Overall very underwhelming and for the price point I would’ve expected at least good food. We’ve been to better steakhouses with exceptional food, cocktails, service, and desserts. In my humble opinion, this place is a skip for me.

Birthday dinner. Asked for candles in the desert, never got one

Great dining experience from start to finish. The food, drinks, service, and ambiance were all excellent.

I've been to American Cut multiple times, usually return because the food is pretty good, and have recommended it to many friends.  However, this visit I had the filet which was surprisingly under seasoned.  Very disappointing.  My friends NY Strip was also under seasoned.  The hostess came by to ask if the food was good and I said our steaks were under seasoned.  She said she would notify the kitchen but Never offered to bring us something else.  Surprising at this price point.

That's a great experience! Thanks to our waitress she was super sweet and super cool lol my son vater had such a great birthday we enjoyed and I love how I had a cake and they came out singing and everything. The Porterhouse was perfectly cooked when I tell you, only every bite was so delicious! The roasted garlic on the side, had to spread some on my steak lol The sauces were all amazing. chefs kiss I had a great night my bf enjoyed so much since it celebrates his birthday. Thank you. Can't wait again with my maid!!