Cosimo Johnny's Pizza - Eastchester

I travel all over the country, and surprisingly, this may just as well be the best slice of Pizza Ive had yet!! It was a fluke i stopped by, but I'm glad I did. Mine was a slice with a sausage and pepperoni. Sausage was a meal in itself. Bravo!!!Food: 5/5

Some of the most delicious pizza around! Perfect thin crust, just the right amount of sauce and cheese. And top it with some of the most delicious sausage and garlic for a delicious slice!Food: 5/5

Very nice people. Terrible pizza. They don't have to worry, Dave Portnoy will never stop by. It's my 4th or 5th time there only because it's close to my house. The pizza is bad, band dough bad toppings. Sorry.

Best Margherita pizza. The sauce is absolute perfection. Nice helpful staff. Love the little bottles of wine in the cooler too! My new favorite place.

Everyone seems to have covered the Pizza but don’t sleep on their Calzones. Traditional Calzone is deep fried not baked…..excellent and the Broccoli Rabe Calzone is in a class by itself!!!!!!Thanx to Cosmo and family for bringing old school Louie and Ernie’s quality to Westchester.