Classic Pizza - Westerville

I visited Classic Pizza on Sunbury last night with my family, and it was the first time for both my boyfriend and me. We absolutely loved it and will definitely be returning. We ordered a Supreme pizza on thin crust and a pepperoni and cheese on thick crust. Everything was bursting with flavor, and the crust was perfectly crispy and crunchy. There was a generous amount of cheese and pepperoni, and the sausage had a delightful kick to it that I really enjoyed. The sauce complemented the toppings beautifully, balancing a slight tanginess with a hint of sweetness, which we appreciated. The staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating, and our pizzas were delivered hot and fresh right to our car! Classic Pizza will definitely become a regular spot for us. We didn't have any leftovers; we polished off everything! Also, the garlic butter was delicious and reminded us of Papa John's.

I absolutely love this restaurant! It’s a small business with just a few locations. I usually stick to their pizza, which is outstanding, and the service is generally excellent. Since the establishment is so small, they only offer carryout and delivery, so don’t expect to dine in. I typically opt for carryout, and from the time I place my order to when I pick it up, it usually takes around 20 minutes.

Excellent cheese pizza! Always hits the mark. They serve some of the best steak subs you can find at a pizza place, bringing back memories of the steak subs from the 1980s. I like to request mayo on the side to get that authentic 1980s flavor. The prices are what you would expect. It’s always great to enjoy good food at a fair price!

I ordered 14 hot pizzas from Classic Pizza for a party I hosted, and I couldn't be happier. The staff was not only professional but also enjoyable to interact with. The pizza was delicious, the prices were reasonable, and the service was excellent! I highly recommend them!

I just started going to this restaurant, and I'm really glad I did! The pizza is amazing. I haven't had the chance to try their other menu items yet, but based on the pizza alone, I'm confident I would be happy with anything else they offer.