Scarborough Fair - Wall Township

The Scar Burger Brioche totally lived up to my expectations!!! The meat was cooked to a perfect medium which is my preference, and I could attest that the burger weighed a good pound. The absolute best sweet potatoes with a crisp crunch with every bite!

What a hidden little secret in its own world seductively hidden is a gem of a very alluring secret hideaway from the ambience outside to the round architectural inside to the wonderful staff to the very well prepared food this is a must do for either a quiet dinner anniversaries holidays anything special this is a must go to

My family and I had a wonderful Christmas dinner yesterday. Joe was our waiter he was just great as well as the other staff members of your restaurant. Very nice variety of menu choices for the holiday. The restaurant was beautifully decorated for the Winter Holidays. I would highly recommend.

My husband surprise me for our Wedding Anniversary! the beautiful rustic, antique and a bit victorian combination was just perfectly designed! Furthermore, the attentiveness of each staff member and the owners was so welcoming and made us feel so comfortable. It was an amazing experience, but wait! the food, the drinks, the deserts, were so delicious! Prices were reasonable for the quality of the place and food, the portions were just right. As we all know . . . sometimes other places might give you smaller portions but this place will give you an amazing experience all around. I will definitely be back, I can still savor the dish and dessert I had! We were just blown away by the service and its genuine way we were treated! God Bless you all and you will not be disappointed when you visit.

We celebrated our 35th anniversary at Scarborough Fair. Our waitress was training a new fellow and with her training him... he'll be great! Unfortunately I am very bad with names. Everyone there was wonderful and the food even better. We were able to get into the alcove seating, need I say more...The atmosphere is romantic plus they decorated the table for us. We started with a half dozen oysters and a quail dish that was fanominal. I'll be going back just the quail alone. I recommend getting a reservation they are so good and usually busy.