Killy's Smokehouse Deli - Sheridan

This restaurant is quite unusual, featuring one of the best pulled pork sandwiches I've ever had. The layout is peculiar, as it boasts a large space with BBQ options, a few cold storage units offering items like local eggs, and various table and chair configurations. It seems like a place that could inspire a visit from the show Restaurant Impossible. This was not our first attempt to dine here. A couple of months ago, we arrived but left without ordering, as we were unsure how to proceed and nobody offered assistance. At that time, we only noticed ribs and fried chicken on display, which wasn't what we were looking for. On our second visit, we encountered a similar scene, so I decided to inquire about the ordering process and the available food. A woman kindly handed us a laminated menu filled with the BBQ options we had anticipated. Placing our order was straightforward, but it took about 15 minutes to receive my sandwich and coleslaw, which felt lengthy, especially since the restaurant was mostly empty. The pulled pork was absolutely delicious! It was generously sauced and piled high on a tasty roll. I chose the house coleslaw over the creamy version and loved it! (The house coleslaw features a vinaigrette and has inspired me to try making a similar dish at home.) I would recommend Killy's for their pulled pork sandwich and coleslaw. I imagine their ribs are also quite good, but I didn’t sample them. Just be prepared for subpar service and an unusual dining environment that seems to be figuring out its identity.

You might be wondering why I rated this restaurant with just 2 stars. The truth is, I absolutely love the food at Killy’s—particularly the shepherd's pie and bangers and mash, which are fantastic. However, I have a major issue. This is the second time in three weeks that I've gone in excited to enjoy one of my favorite dishes, only to find out that there’s no cook available. I understand that staffing can be tough, but if you're unable to have a cook on hand, it might be best to remove those items from the menu entirely. Instead, focus on offering only the dishes that can be prepared in bulk. I’ll continue to check for updates on Facebook, but if I see a "Cook Wanted" sign again, I might not return. I really hope things improve because I miss my favorite pub food.

My nephew and I had lunch at Killy's, and everything was excellent. The food and service were both fantastic. I would rate the food a perfect 5/5.

Good fried chicken, smoked ribs, chicken it's very delicious Food: 5/5

Most often buy their chicken for take out. Breasts, thighs, wings, drumsticks and tenders. Sometimes the delicious ribs. Consistently delicious food.Food: 5/5