Ram's Head Inn - SHELTER ISLAND

Went there Saturday, 5th of November, 2022 for brunch. We ordered Lobster Quiche, Cauliflower Artichoke soup, Clam Chowder, and RHI burger. What followed: two days of severe food poisoning to the point of almost fainting from weakness and dehydration. Icalled them back today to inform them of this. Their response: Call the suffolk county health department .

We are extremely disappointed with our stay and would never go back. In addition to subpar amenities, the service was rude and unhelpful. We paid extra for a nice room for a special occasion. It was so small we couldn't even wash our face in the tiny sinkand the shower has no ledge to even put a bar of soap. The shower door was broken so every time we used it water covered thebathroom floor. The room was essentially the bed, with no extra space. I am 8 months pregnant and needed to do some exercises. Iasked for access to the wellness center because there was no space in the room, and was told no. Then, we arrived to thebreakfast that ends at 10 at 930 one morning and there was no coffee left... when we asked for more the woman said no, just usethe Keurig. Both nights we dined at The Rams Head, our appetizers came out before our drinks and the second night we had toremind our server to bring them at all. If our stay had been a third of the price, we probably would have given four starsbecause that is the value of the service we got. But this place is just so overpriced. It was a real bummer.

We had a great time, loved the accommodations, and the staff was excellent! Highly recommend taking a look at this place if you are wanting a quiet getaway on the island.

Just went for a dinner. Have always admired Rams Head beauty and history. Enjoyed dining on the porch however our party of four found the food to be mediocre. My pasta dish was sitting on a bed of overly salted mushrooms and overall flavor of pasta wasdisappointing. The desserts were also pretty mediocre. The profiteroles were not classic with a chocolate sauce made with heavycream and so indulgent instead we got a taste of overipe banana!. : Here's hoping next season will bring a chef who dazzlesthe diners.

This review is a bit different? we never made it however when we do I can?t wait. My sister and I finally found a weekend that worked for a getaway. Due to unfortunate unforeseen circumstances we had to cancel. The front desk was beyond understanding andhelpful to us according to all of the hotel policies etc. in fact from booking the actual room I was beyond pleased with thehospitality. Everyone was so enthusiastic patient and answered all of our questions. Customer service is hard to come by thesedays and although this didn?t work out I really look forward to rebooking our stay