Johnnys Pizzeria And - Rock Tavern

The experience was not great! I ordered a simple pizza and a pepperoni slice, and the total came to $8.80. The crust was overcooked and tough, almost as if it had been boiled. I could easily roll the dough back into a ball. The pepperoni was also boiled, and there was barely any sauce on the pizzas, giving them a bland, watery taste. They flopped quite a bit. I requested my pizza to be extra crispy, but it didn't turn out that way. Overall, the flavor felt very artificial. I ended up tossing both slices and felt sick afterwards. I’d recommend getting a Red Baron frozen pizza instead; save your money and go elsewhere!

I'm from Georgia, and I had to try New York pizza! It was incredible! The taco pizza was fantastic, and the garlic knots were some of the best I've ever had! You have to check this place out!

I recently ordered food from Johnny's Pizzeria for the first time, and I really enjoyed my breakfast burger along with a side of chicken soup! The staff were friendly and welcoming. I’ll definitely return to try their pizza.

My husband fell in love with Johnny's pizza since we moved to the Ulster County area. He's pretty special what he supplies for pizza and Johnny?s! Its favorites are traditional cheese, beacon and Buffalo chicken pizzas. The staff is always nice and we? ve NEVER had a problem with accuracy or quality. If you re in the area, try it out, you won't be sad!

Ordered for pickup not expecting much, but was surprised at the quality of the service and food we received. Garlic knots were tasty and the pizza crust had a good crisp. The owner was very friendly and made us feel like regulars, will definitely go back next time I?m in town.