Sizzle Pie - Reno

We are from Oregon (where this company originated) but I haven’t eaten Sizzle Pie since going Vegan. So I had to get it here while on vacay. I ordered the Buffalo 666 and then a large side of garlic rolls with the ranch and red sauce. It was exactly how I expected it to be, freaking delicious!

I first tried Sizzle Pie on a trip to Portland, and it was AMAZING. Their vegan pies are honestly some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Extremely flavorful, fun ideas, unique combinations- they use violife cheese too, which is a MAJOR plus. And the soycurls they offer are now one of my favorite things to get on a pizza. My portland experience made me SO excited that one was opening up in Reno, but unfortunately, my expectations fell shorter than I thought they would. The pizza is still amazing, don’t get me wrong. I’ve never had any problem with their pick up experience, or the pizzas I’ve ordered through pick up. Always quick, order is correct, and the food is delicious. But if you’re looking to dine in, you may not get the experience you’d like. It’s usually pretty busy, but even when it’s not, customer service falls short. My last visit to Sizzle Pie to dine in was terrible, to say the least. The staff was rude, and seemed aloof. Lost track of our order on three separate occasions, and we waited for our full order for almost 3 hours on a night where there were only about 5 customers, majority of which were seated at the bar just getting drinks. After pitching a slight fit when we waited for 75+ minutes for a side of garlic knots, on top of waiting over an hour for a large pizza, they offered to refund us. Instead, the refund never came we were given coupons for our next visit. The bartender was incredibly rude tried to refuse service to my girlfriend on account of her “not looking 21” even though she’s almost 22. He looked over her ID about 10 times before apologizing for his misunderstanding. If you want to try Sizzle Pie, my best recommendation is to just order pick up, or have it delivered if you live in the Reno area. The wait time, and customer service isn’t worth dining in the restaurant. They really make amazing pizzas here, and their vegan options are immense, so it truly makes me sad to write this review. I’ll probably still order from them occasionally online because I’ve never had a better vegan pizza in Reno, but I’ll most likely never step foot in the restaurant again to dine in, unless they get some new staff that don’t have their heads in the clouds 24/7. Great pizza, but not so great customer service. Like I said, save yourself the pain of dining in by just ordering online. For some reason they’re better about delivery pick up than they are about customers actually dining in the restaurant itself.

I understand that because this isn't a fully vegan or vegetarian restaurant I can't actually give it five stars but man does it deserve it! I was only expecting one or maybe two slices to get to go but they had three and all were absolutely amazing. they had the void, steve caballero angel of doom available- incredible. the void is just plain cheese w red sauce but that is my ultimate favorite! steve had fake meats, peppers, onions and dollops of tofu cheese... woah. and the angel was the best i think, with pineapple, jalapeños, almonds cilantro w cheese and red sauce... what the heck!! even my omni brother got a slice of that one and was super impressed. they ALSO have garlic knots that are automatically vegan AND 5 different dipping sauces... yes please. i'm excited to come back to the West coast literally just to try more of this pizza

Pizza by the slice. Three vegan pizza options from vegan cheese to veggie. Kids loved the vegan cheese. They even tried the veggie, which I thought was amazing, and liked it. We also got the garlic knots, which they liked so much we had to order more. Would definitely give five stars if the app allowed it.

We got the Grazing Arizona and it was delicious. The Thrilling-Bacon is ridiculously super-smoking and next level. All about topping were really solid and loaded. Crust was beautiful and chewing, and of course got some vegan ranch. The cinnamon nodes were also delish, like small mini cinnamon rolls. Awesome is the Icing Standard vegan. Yes, it is a little expensive as some others mentioned, but was not disappointed and worth a little splurge than special dinner.