Eaton's Fresh Pizza - Oshkosh

This is my favorite take-out pizza place over many years. They get like 90% of my business because they are so consistently GOOD. Their pizzas have the right zest in the sauce, more than enough cheese, and always the right proportions of toppings. I have never gotten a bad pizza here and highly recommend them. The staff is friendly and the service is fast.

Great take and bake pizza! They have premade frozen or have one fresh made to order. Call in ahead or they'll make it for you quickly while you wait. The cheese and sauce are great and the rest of the ingredients are top shelf. Some of my favorite pizza.

Normally I love going to Eatons but tonight was the first time I was turned away. I walked in since I saw the open sign was still lit up. It was ten minutes til 8. They already had everything wrapped up so they said they couldn't make me anything. I understand it being close to 8 but you're still open right? If not put the closed sign up!! Also, please wait to wrap up everything until you're actually closed. I would have loved a cauliflower pizza but being turned away honestly makes me not want to go back.

Absolutely love Eatons Subs! So fresh! A few prefabricated pizzas too! So practical to have this option too! The staff is always so friendly!

It took a bit to get my food but after that first bite of my garlic chicken bacon ranch sub... So worth the little extra wait. Oh I also snagged a pizza of the nearly same variety.!