The Maids Cottage - Newmarket

We ordered over 150 butter tarts from this place as our wedding favors, and they were a tremendous success! The staff did an excellent job managing our order and ensuring everything was prepared on time. Without a doubt, these are the best butter tarts I've ever tasted.

Web for the buttertarts. Not that impressed 4 dollars for one a tart is a bit expensive filling was nice too much crust for my

The sisters who run this restaurant are truly wonderful. I stopped by once for breakfast and had a delicious homemade quiche along with some of the best French toast I've ever had, not realizing I was at the home of Ontario's finest butter tarts. I picked up a few on my way out for my family, who adore them, and now I've had to come back multiple times for more. The customer service is consistently excellent, and there's always a great variety of tarts available. If you're in the area, you definitely don't want to miss out on this gem!

I first heard about Maids Cottage when I visited Midland Ontario, the home of a renown butter tart festival. Maids cottage had been awarded a first place win for their butter tarts. When I visited the store I was not disappointed. The best butter tarts I had had in years. Plus there was so many choices, I will return.

I first discovered Maids Cottage while visiting Midland, Ontario, famous for its renowned butter tart festival. Maids Cottage had won first place for their butter tarts, and when I finally visited the shop, I was not disappointed. They were the best butter tarts I’ve had in years! Additionally, there were so many options to choose from that I can’t wait to go back.