Hoagie Barmichaels - New Windsor

Our experience last week was quite different from what others have posted here. Unfortunately, I would have to rate it poorly! The bar area is narrow with a low ceiling, which made it really noisy. It's...

I enjoy this place; they have a great selection of beers, and the food is delicious. However, my complaint is about being told at 11:30 PM that the kitchen is closed while you continue to serve food...

We walked in and immediately turned around and left. The smell hit us as soon as we entered, and it was overwhelming. The staff and locals gave us looks that made it clear we didn't seem to belong there.

Our experience last week was quite different from what others have described here, and unfortunately, it was not a good one. The bar is narrow with a low ceiling, making it very loud. The setup for music is poorly planned, as it’s cramped in a back room. The bartender, who had to take on multiple roles—bartender, buyer, and supplier—was clearly overwhelmed, and it really didn’t work. There was practically no table service. The smoking area on the side seems to draw in those at the last three tables, adding to the unpleasant atmosphere with a strong smell of nicotine. We noticed two couples sitting near us who ended up leaving. We ordered two drinks but decided against food and left shortly after. This place might work for a small group, but parking is extremely limited. We ended up parking near the garbage bins, and some customers had parked in a way that blocked the entrance. Overall, it was a really disappointing experience, but I commend the bartender for staying calm despite the chaos.

"Definitely check this place out! It's perfect for a quick snack while you're shopping. The food was wonderful and the beer was nice and cold. The bartender was very friendly too. I’ll definitely be returning!" - Thyssen