Horseneck Tavern - Montclair

**Meal Type:** Dinner **Price Range:** $20–30 per person **Food:** 5/5 **Service:** 3/5 **Atmosphere:** 5/5 If you're looking for a delightful dining experience, this restaurant is a solid choice. The food is exceptional, earning a perfect score of 5 out of 5. I highly recommend trying the Spinach Dip and the Beef Burger; both dishes are truly delicious. The atmosphere of the place is also outstanding, creating a pleasant and inviting environment for dinner. The only downside was the service, which I rated a 3 out of 5. While it wasn't terrible, there is definitely room for improvement. Overall, it's a great spot for a lovely evening out!

This restaurant feels generic and lacks character, with overpriced dishes that don't impress. The food and service both receive a modest rating of 3, while the atmosphere falls flat at just 2. Overall, it was a disappointing experience.

In New Jersey, when the deceased aren't casting their votes, they're often busy creating lists of the best restaurants in the state—there are countless options! Among them, you’ll find the Horseneck Tavern, a local gem that truly stands out. The menu offers a wide range of options, from sandwiches to steaks, with a delicious selection of seafood. The service is top-notch, and that crab cake sandwich I had will linger in my memory for weeks to come. The atmosphere is lively but not overwhelming, making it one of those rare places perfect for both a discreet business lunch and a casual first date. Wake the dead—the Horseneck Tavern is a true winner, deserving of a solid five stars!

I'm giving Horseneck a 5 this time around. We visited a few years ago and didn't have the greatest experiences with the food. The appetizers were good, but the main dishes fell short. However, we decided to return, and we were blown away! From the hostess, Nicole (if I got her name right), to our server, Darren, everything was exceptional. I had the best chicken pot pie I've ever tasted (no offense to my wife—hers is good too!). Darren is such a warm and friendly person, and a great conversationalist. It's becoming rare to receive such excellent service these days, and the food was truly fantastic. We will definitely be back soon!

**Dine-in Experience: Dinner** **Food:** 4/5 **Service:** 4/5 **Atmosphere:** 4/5 The dinner experience at this restaurant was delightful. The food was flavorful and well-prepared, earning a solid rating of 4. The service was attentive and friendly, also deserving of a 4. As for the atmosphere, it was inviting and comfortable, contributing positively to the overall experience, which I would rate at 4 as well.