Tony's New York Pizza - Greencastle

This place used to be the best pizza when the old man was around. now very little cheese crust very hard on the floor and I h8 to say, but brother pizza has beaten her

The food was okay the price kind of Deep and they got to fix the problem with the bugs

This has always been my favorite pizza spot, and I've often been pretty critical about my dining experiences. However, I finally took my dad's advice and stopped calling the place every three minutes, getting frustrated when they didn’t pick up. When I visited in person, I found it packed with customers, and everyone was really friendly—especially the new staff. We had a great conversation about our favorite beach! A big thank you to the owner and the management for creating such a welcoming atmosphere.

The pizza looked fantastic and the kids really enjoyed it. However, I ordered the eggplant dish and found it to have more breading than actual eggplant.

I had a quick lunch today and decided to try the lunch special, which included two slices of cheese and a Coke. The advertised price was $4.30, but this is for...