Fella's - City of New York

Sadly this place is one of the only open on the island after hours... for now. My burger and calamari were ordered over the phone. I was given a 20 min eta. It took a little longer than 20 but it was nominal. The calamari came unseasoned with tartar and not marinara sauce... im sorry did I order crab cakes? Also have you ever heard of old bay? If you 're not a fan of seasoning don 't serve food that demands it. My 6 year old can handle that one The burger was obviously from the freezer and not fresh. It was warmed. Not cooked. Do you know how hard it is to serve a frozen patty still raw? That takes talent. Thankfully I saw it before I got too far into it. I ordered the Wayne burger. I guess it was meant to come partially raw with raw accoutrements. The fries... well they 're on par with the rest. Soggy, raw and... not worth the order. Maybe I 'll try to feed this to my dog... Actually I won 't. He deserves better.

Great place to go, and Nastassja the bartender is world class. Her husband is one lucky guy!

This place is a hidden gem! Our bartender Brooklyn is the bomb.com! She had the drinks flowing and she didnt short end us! Let's not mention how good the food was. I could barely finish my portion. Plus, the place is not mixy at all : I would definitely go here again! Definitely worth a Saturday night visit with you and your boo, your homegirls or a man that's looking to spend money on you.

First time ever here have to say hands down food was great. It feels like your in a classic style friend and family style dive bars with a twist, I had the buffalo wings and the steak quesadillas and it was beyond great. Good customer service everybody makes you feel like your family and at home. I felt comfortable and after the first drink the bartender actually knew and remembered my name and that's always a great feeling. Tons of different drinks, good space, pool table sports on all TV's yeah definitely recommending this place for friend and family. Thank you TRACY...

In the best way: it is the only legit dive bar on the island. It is where the rest of the island comes to unwind after their shifts, and that says something. As does having the only pool table around. Give the bartenders lip and they'll double down on you. Real people, real place. Plus, agree with others : food is where it's at (so long as you are getting Mexican or burgers; can't comment on anything else: burritos are bomb)