Noah's Bagels - Chatham

$12 for a plain bagel with two meager slices of nova? And a ‘non cash’ surcharge to boot? Ridiculous. Worse, they arrogantly smeared at my suggestion this was too expensive. I was a loyal customer for 8 years. Their bagels are ok, sandwiches decent.but they microwave their eggs and the Staff makes you feel like they’re doing you a favor. $12.50 for a stingy acme nova bagel with attitude? No way. I’ll never go back. Avoid.

Best bagels around. Whenever we are back in town- we have to go to Noah's to pick up a bagel... or a bag of bagels... They are the best and the staff is so nice. Highly recommend. They also used to be known for their cream cheese spread, which doesn't seem to be as much anymore. That's the only thing I miss.

The food is great, but the service leaves much to be desired. When the owner is not present, the staff can be quite impolite.

The bagel I received was thin, and the cream cheese was pretty standard—not worth the $4.25 I paid ($4.55 with tax). Additionally, it’s a bit of a hassle to get in and out of the shop if you're heading toward Florham Park or Madison. Unfortunately, this place won't be making it onto my regular list of dining options. I'll stick with Craft Bagel in Berkeley Heights ($2.99) or O'Bagel in Stirling ($3.20) instead.

Noah's Bagel Shop is quite disappointing. They claim to have the best bagels in New Jersey, but honestly, my half-blind cat could create better bagels from her fur. The staff is consistently rude, and the prices are excessive. My experience there was frustrating; I felt utterly disrespected by the employees and ended up paying $12 for a plain bagel with a few toppings that honestly tasted terrible. Additionally, I know the owner and his family personally. He strikes me as someone who enjoys meddling in the lives of his spoiled son's college roommates and seems rather aimless in life. I've never encountered anyone so pretentious. If you want to avoid supporting someone like him, I suggest visiting any other bagel shop in New Jersey. I can guarantee you'll find better bagels for half the price.