Ardshiel - Campbeltown

Firstly, the TV took up most of the desk space and ideally should have been wall-mounted to free up room. Additionally, it was extremely hot in the room, and there was no fan provided, so I had to go out and buy one for comfort. Lastly, the bathroom lacked any hanging space, which meant all our clothes ended up on the floor. The wash basin was the smallest I've ever seen, and combined with a large waterfall tap, it caused water to spill onto the floor every time we used it. It's unfortunate that such simple fixes could enhance an otherwise nice hotel experience.

Food and drinks: Excellent selection and value. Service: 5 stars. Location: 5 stars. Hotel highlights: Exceptional value.

We had our first experience at the Ardshiel, where we stayed for two nights, and I would highly recommend it. The food was exceptional; I enjoyed the venison ragu one night and the ribs the next, and both dishes were fantastic. The whisky bar is impressive, featuring a wide selection of exceptional bottles. The staff was friendly and accommodating, always ready to help. The rooms were comfortable, and the bathrooms were nicely updated. Overall, combined with the Springbank tour and the Cadenhead warehouse tasting, it made for a wonderful start to our vacation.

We were only at the restaurant. Great! We had great dinners. Starter, mains and desserts were very delicious. Food drinks: Great meals, beers, and single malts! Service: 5 Location: 5 Hotel highlights: Romantic

Given that the Ardshiel is an institution in Campbeltown we were excited to stay but other than the whisky bar (incredible selection with very fair pricing) we were underwhelmed by the food, service and especially the rooms (renovated, but to the bare minimum standards with very uncomfortable beds). In the end if we'd gotten some cheer or a smile from at least one staff member that could have helped us to overlook the lackluster food and rooms, but everyone was so stiff and dour that we were relieved to only be staying one night. Summary: amazing whisky selection but recommended to eat and sleep elsewhere.