Hoof And Barrel - York

This restaurant has a fantastic atmosphere, excellent service, and the food is amazing. Our large group was seated promptly and our food was served quickly.

Consistently excellent! The staff is wonderful, which is crucial because it sets the tone for the high-quality food that follows.

I cannot praise this family-owned restaurant enough. The service was fantastic, the menu had a wide variety of options, the flavors were excellent, the portions were generous, and the prices were very reasonable. The drinks were plentiful and they were able to easily accommodate our large party of about 20 people. My only regret is not trying the **** Mary. I only saw it and its ingredients after we finished our meal!

If you go here absolutely do not order a steak. I don't know what cuts they get but it can't be what they advertise on the menu. I got their prime ribeye steak and there is no way it was a prime cut of meat. It had 0 fat in it and tasted just like a hamburger patty. They use 0 salt and 0 pepper and no butter or anything when they cook their steaks. I've had their sirloin steak twice and their prime ribeye once and you can't tell the difference between the two. You can literally buy a $6 chuck steak from food Lion and cook it on the stovetop and it's 3x as good as what they serve. Rest of their food is great and the service is amazing. If not for that they would get 2 stars at best.

First time eating there tonight. The Double D sandwich was delicious. Great selection of food and drinks. Will be back ASAP.