Crystal Inn - West Milford

The food was good, but our server disappeared and another server and the hosts had to fill up. Loved the atmosphere.

Haven't been here in awhile. Ordered some food for take out. Doesnt seem to be as good as it was. Still give it a 4

Oysters had no taste. I've been getting the personal pizza for a few years...always came with thin crust. Now crust was very thick, toppings paper thin. What happened?

We’ve eaten here twice now. Both times the food and service have been great. Chicken Marsala, wings, and the pizza were the highlights for me. Only negative was the crème brûlée it was ice cold and the texture was way off. Would not order that again. Overall positive experience though.

Our first time to visit this quaint local Inn. We tried an inexpensive meal to check out the chefs fare. We were pleasantly surprised at the quality of the food although when we requested a rare cook it came out medium rare. We intend on returning to sample other interesting items on the menu. The staff and owners were very friendly and accommodating with repeated visits to check on our needs.