Bari Pizzeria - West Allis

Ok. This place would have EASILY gotten a 5 star from me, but the fact that over $100 worth of brand new clothing is ruined has honestly affected my review. Ordered online tonight, 30 min for pickup. My husband arrived and the food was ready within a few minutes of the time given. We ordered 2 pizzas and Da Bomb cheesy garlic bread. Reviews online made me pay the $11 for this item! 11 BREAD Both pizzas were prepared exactly as ordered, the split topping pizza was sequestered so perfectly not a single topping crossed into the other side. Quite impressive! The kids pizza was basic, cause kids, pepperoni. It was thin, crispy and perfectly cooked and seasoned. Da Bomb was worth every cent of the $11. Fresh garlic, home made sauce, pouring with cheese. Simply divine. We were even given 2 bags filled with cookies, which the kids will love. Here's where this goes awry. My husband picked up the food and as transporting it into the car, the box from DaBomb drained grease all over him. His t shirt, shorts he just took the tag off of today and brand new UGG slides are all now ruined. It would have been simple and appreciated it he was warned that the box could leak, or if this item was placed into a bag. All in all, I'm sure we will return because good pizza is appreciated in this house!

I have tried this place a couple of times now and it is amazing. They do pick up or delivery and I was impressed by the food each time. Paninis made in a press! Pizza was great each time. We have ordeeed several kinds. The garlic bread is really good. They have many gluten free options too! Even the desserts are made fresh and incredible! I have not had one bad thing here. Definitely worth a try.

Unfortunately the chef had to sell. the new owner seems really nice and friendly, but the pizza is simply not the same. pizza came in a strange box that didn't keep it warm and the taste of the pizza itself was simply okay. nothing like the old bari. To be honest, the new owner should change the name, because people naturally compare him with the old place. best to restart with a new name and concept.

I tried this place through doordash, so it's just about eating. I ordered the bomb and the pizza fritte. the quality of both was amazing, but holy moly was fat. under the bomb there was a huge puddle of fat and oil, we had to drop it to a serviette before eating. Yeah, there's a lot of cheese, but the fat level just ruins it a little. I will say it was clearly better the next day than we heated it again; as the fat had left out by then. the sauce was great, but super garlicky. the pizza fry was pretty good, and I would definitely try her pizza next time bc the reviews for that are great.

Just ordered delivery. Wings, pizza, and Da-Bomb. Oh lordy, da-bomb is seriously the guiltiest flavor pleasure I may have ever experienced. The bread is so perfectly chewy, loaded with garlicky cheese. Heaven for real. I'm going to have a hard time avoiding this choice in the very near future.