Kiss Me Cookie - Webster

Ordered a dozen specialty cupcakes and mixed those up with a dozen Wegman cupcakes to lighten the birthday costs. The cupcakes looked nice, albeit, abit light on the frosting. The cupcakes, themselves, were very dense and too wet/chewy. Everyone preferred the wegmans cupcakes taste.The company was easy enough to work with and completed the order, I didn’t get a price quote when placing the order because the manager wasn’t in. I was told they would call to let me know the price but did not get that call. I tried calling 2 days before the party to confirm they were going to do the order and get the price quote but there was no answer—I did leave a VM with my number to call back but never got a return call. Was abit worried the order was never done with lack of communication, but they were ready to go when we went to pick up and looked nice. The price I paid was more than what was listed on the website.

If i could give them more stars i would!Jenelle is just the sweetest !

My favorite cookie shop! Golden delicious are the best cookies ever. If I can't get to the bakery, I'll get their products at Shutt's. I've gotten a cookie cake from there too. Just love this place. A total must for cookie lovers!

The staff was very respectful and kind however, the cookies themselves were bland and very dry. I bought a dozen for my girlfriend and I to share and we personally didn’t enjoy them to the fullest potential I would rate 4/10

Bright and clean shop! Owner/staff were great but the cookies were just nothing special... ? and I have had cookies from here to California.