Holy Cow Deli - Watkins Glen

My husband went in and placed an order. He ordered two subs and a chicken tender basket. 30mins went by and nothing. Then an hour went by and we finally got our food after asking what was going on. We traveled 45mins into town to try this out. We understand things happen, the problem came into play that our fries were cold and our sandwich was made incorrectly. We had an family event planned that we had to head out to since we were already late due to waiting for an hr for food. I called the store and talked to a women named Kelly? ...and explained the situation to her..... she told me that I could turn back around and bring the food back to her and she would make the order within 5mins why wasn't this the case the first time? . If not then we would have to hold on to the food and bring it back to her later tonight and then she would have them remake it. So I have to hold on to food that is no good due to it being cold and wrong even after you made us wait an hour? Our in laws ordered before us, got their food , sat down, ate and walked their dog before we even got ours. We didn't have time to simply turn around and go back. I explained to her that we were late for the event and we were close to an hour away and wouldn't be able to come back. We were really looking forward to having a really good lunch but that is not the case.Adding on the fact that 2 subs and chicken tenders was almost $45!!!!!It would have been different if she told us to come back.sometime this week and she would remake just the items that were messed up but to ask us to hold on to the items is a bit much.Never eating here again.

If you eat in, you get chips included with your Philly. Apparently with to go orders chips are not included but you pay the same. They would not work with me on that. Other than weird stuff like that, It’s a decent deli

Place is spacious clean with plenty parking in main road. Sandwich selection was normal, not very exciting options, mainly subs. Would have liked to see more creative sandwiches since it boasts Wild Boar cold cuts. Also some choices of healthier bread wound be nice besides white subs.

Stopped here for a quick lunch on our way to Watkins Glenn. Got the cheesesteak and the Ruben -both super good!

We got sandwiches to take on our hike in Watkins Glen State Park. They were good, but ask them to go light on the dressings or sauces one of the sandwiches was a little leaky.