Papa Luke's - Village of Monticello

I drove by and noticed it's closed for good. It shut down a couple of weeks ago, and there’s a for sale sign out front. The ice cream stand next door has also been closed all summer. I hope someone buys both places and reopens them. It's disappointing to see a local business go under. Now, the nearest option is Brother Bruno's, just down the road.

The pizzas here are absolutely delicious! I also tried the meatball parm, which was flavorful and packed with meat. It was a generous portion, too! The staff member at the counter was really nice and even gave me a card to get stamped for a chance to earn free pizza.

Papa Luke's special fresh cheese pizza pie is absolutely outstanding! There’s nothing in New York City or Long Island that even comes close!

If you like fresh, delicious cheese pizza pie, you must try Papa Luke's special and asked for it well done! It's out of this world. However, they do say they offer delivery, but 2 out of 3 times, I had to pick up!

Been a customer here for years. My favorite pizza is the shrimp scampi but you have to give him some time to make it. Wings are good.