Mary's Deli - Village of Fredonia

The pizza was tasty, but I ordered a whole sub and was disappointed to find only four pieces of capicola on it. For $14, I expected a lot more. I won't be buying a sub from there again.

The pizza was great, but I ordered a whole sub that only had four pieces of capicola on it. For $14, I expected more. I won’t be ordering a sub again.

Pizza sauce is too sweet... like tomato syrup. So-so papal white flour crust. Never again.

Mary's has always been the best place to get pizza in the Dunkirk/Fredonia area. Best sauce, crust and chicken wings, EVER! It is especially fantastic when Barb works!

When I came home from picking up an order from Mary's Deli, I noticed it was made incorrectly. Things I specifically asked not to be put on the sub ended up on it. Not only was the order wrong, but if we were going to eat it we had to assemble it ourselves. The ingredients were thrown into the sub wrappings rather than on the roll. So, I went back. All they did to meet the needs of their upset customer was figure out which of the employees was to blame. No progress was made to fix my order or compensate for the mistake, and after about 5 minutes of the workers playing the blame game I walked out, leaving the sloppy mess of a sub on the counter and without receiving a refund. No attempt was made to ensure I left happy with my order.