Montauk Seafood Company

Incredible fresh oysters and small bites! This place is better than any restaurant we've tried in Montauk. We had to return after our first dozen because they were so good! Although there wasn't on-site seating, the food was neatly packaged, making it easy to take to any picnic spot in the city.

This is a fantastic spot to indulge in fresh oysters and cozy moments. The staff is incredibly friendly, and you absolutely must try her smoked fish. There's a wide variety of crackers, olives, spreads, and spices to choose from. I can't wait to return for any event!

At the Scottish farm, I was greeted with laughter but ultimately left disappointed. The food lacked flavor and had a bland texture. I've learned my lesson: it's best to buy locally.

Montauk has been lucky to have this new fish market in the city. it is clean as a pfeife, and the fish is as local and fresh as it gets. peterson makes it easy to snap everything they need to put together a minute, no fuss, gourmet menu that will be sure to impress their guests. it is obvious that the owners take much pride in their business. I will be a recurring customer. they have the best garnel and cocktail sauce. in the did, everyone in my family agrees that it is the best we ever had!

Fresh Local Seafood Hand Picked by Wes Daily.We also enjoyed the Steak he carries..highly recommend this Market!!!