Fratellis Italian Eatery

Pros: Calzones and Strombolis are awesome, especially the chicken/bacon/ranch one. Definitely worth ordering again (and we have). Pizza is a pro too, very traditional NY style; haven't tried their other types (Grandmas/Sicilian) but will. They will do curbside as well if you ask nicely. Cons: With COVID, they are a bit on the slow side, so order ahead and be patient, it is a pandemic after all. A bit pricey for a quick to-go spot, but I imagine the rent is pretty high in the village. Definitely support your local businesses!

Best pizza within 20 minutes.. little expensive (one topping large gonna run you over $20 with tax, they cook the pepperoni nicely though). It 's also difficult to get. Let me explain. Walked in here a little after 7 one night to order a pie.. and was refused because the pizza cook had left . Another time, when I was able to successfully order a pizza, they said it would be ready in 40 minutes. I arrive 45 minutes later and was literally waiting another 35 minutes. They took $2 off the pie at least- but by that estimate my time is worth $4 an hour. Nah, it should have been at least 50% off after wasting almost an hour of my time. Also, get your online information correct. I have called this place on 3 different occasions within the open times as stated by their own website, google and yelp... only to have the phone ring endlessly and never be picked up.

Amazing pizza, crust is crunchy and the food is made fresh , great prompt service. Many options available including great ice coffee for a great price.

There's something special about Fratellies. Very good food and it's like family. The staff and kitchen crew are great.

My husband went in there last night and got a sandwich for himself and the not so classic Caesar salad for me. The sandwich was good, albeit on the small side. And my salad would have been great had it come with dressing. Which they obviously forgot. We didn 't realize this until he got home, then had to go out again for dressing. That kind of mistakes should not happen. That 's what happens when we stray from the far superior S-Port.