Abrams Bakery - Stone Mills

Just had the best date square I have ever had from this hidden gem! Their lunch sandwiches are amazing and their pizza even more so. How lucky we are that this little bakery opened up near us. They have the perfect amount of choices for everyone and you can't help but love the staff that run it. Looking forward to trying their soft pretzels. Yum.

The minute you walk in and are greeted with big smiles and cheery "hellos" you know you are in the right spot. Delicious soups and sandwiches......Donna's scones, squares and pies (not to mention all her other treats) are to die for....and the pizza!!! amazing. Thank you to this wonderful family for making Rogues' Hollow (Newburgh) and great place both to visit and to live.

This has to be my favorite place to stop and visit with Trever and Donna Abraham. Not only are they the most friendliest people but they also bake the best cakes and bread in the region. I will stop anytime I pass through Newburgh.

Great local bakery with a quaint hometown feel. Friendly staff and fresh bakery items. Take the drive to Newburgh you won't be disappointed.

Trever, Donna & Cassandra are incredible and very dedicated to their work and perfecting their craft. I visit the bakery weekly - it's a highlight for my son! The baked goods, pizza and sandwiches are fantastic! Never had anything I wouldn't get again! The Pop Shop beverages are the icing on the cupcake!