White Star Tavern - Staunton

We are visiting North Carolina for a night and chose this restaurant for dinner. It far exceeded our expectations! The menu offered a wide variety of options. The homemade bread was absolutely delicious. Our meals were fantastic, and as a nice touch, they even treated us to a complimentary cup of peppermint ice cream. Unfortunately, I can't remember the name of our waitress, but she was incredibly kind and helpful. Highly recommended!

The food was exceptional! The service was wonderful; Robin attended to us with utmost care. If you're in the area, you must give this place a try—you won't be disappointed. They have the best roasted green tomatoes I've ever tasted!

I didn't stay for too long, but we were in town celebrating with family, and it was just as I remembered! We enjoyed Oysters Rockefeller (maybe a little less bacon next time), ribs, chicken, Cajun Chicken Alfredo, crab cakes, and lamb chops, all of which were delicious. The drinks were fantastic! The service was excellent as well! I gave it 4 stars because the waiting situation was a bit chaotic.

Our dinners were wonderful. Our server went up to recommend a local beer to my daughter. I love the fact that a historic building had a second chance and saved from the wreckball. Mill Street Grill is amazing!

Wow!!! The food here is delicious! We were visiting Staunton and was recommended to go here by our hotel front desk lady. It did not disappoint! The place was bustling on a Friday night. We didn’t mind the wait for a table. The staff was on point with juggling the hostess stand, answering calls, and handing out take-out orders. I overheard a conversation from a call in when they had to tell the customer that they were no longer fulfilling take-out orders because they were so busy. It sounded like the person on the other end was giving the hostess a hard time, but she was very sweet to them and never lost her patience. Our waitress was great and the food was AWESOME! The bread they give you with specialty butter is so good. My husband got some of the best prime ribs we had ever tasted. We joked that we hadn’t eaten that good since our cruise last year! I got the artichoke chicken and that was great too! They bring you a small complimentary ice cream at the end of your meal too! The atmosphere is unique- it’s an old flour mill. Would highly recommend going here and we plan on going back!