Millie's Of Staten Island

Went out with a group of friends. Took reservations which was nice. Some of us opted for the prefix which was a salad, 2 meatballs, A pizza and a cannoli. The pannarella salad was amazing... croutons, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes in a balsamic truffle dressing. It was incredible. Opted for marinara meatballs. Considering we are all of Italian heritage and have been making meatballs and sauce for years.... millies were dry and disappointing. At least 12 choices of pizza to choose from (coal fired or wood fired). While we all would have preferred the thinner type they were only offered with wood fired choices). We had the truffle (awesome flavors), soprasata (tasty), the white pie (not our favorite...it needed more flavor) we all agreed the eggplant was the winner!!! The eggplant pie was incredible!!! A friend ordered charbroiled oysters. They were very tasty but were quite small. For dessert the cannoli was included. Shell was nice and crisp and cream was delicious. However, when you picked it up... there was only cream added to the ends (not filled). That was disappointing. Last comment...our waitress, Ariana, was patient, funny and a pleasure!!! Had the cannoli topped Nutella pie which was absolutely delicious. Highly recommend. Will go back and have panarella salad, eggplant pizza and Nutella pie!

My husband and I enjoyed the food and the service. Cold antipasto and Calzone were delicious and portions were generous. We can't wait to enjoy again.

Pizza is always good. the prices are a bit high, but it is worth it. no longer everything they can eat for 20.00 meatball vodka cake is one must try.

Excellent Highly recommend. We had 3 of the coal fired pizzas. It was light and crispy, crust was delicious. So good definitely going back soon.

Millie’s is an absolutely incredible restaurant on so many flats. in the did it is from my experience more than a restaurant. it's a dining room experience, the second-to-lower. I had their vodka pies, on so many flat, their salates especially the strawberry w/ goat cheese and their charred oysters, deliciously filled and unbelievable. in addition, the personal is impeccable. if you need something, the personal is always there and you are more than just a guest. you're family.