Peace Pie - St. Augustine

Amazing flavors. Fresh ice cream with generous portion on crispy cookies. An absolute must in St Augustine !!

The ice cream sandwiches were amazing! I got the peanut butter cookie dough. My husband got the peaches and cream.....the size of those sandwiches were great for the price

The positives: everything is fantastic. The neutral point: the cookies are on the hard side, rather than soft, but they taste amazing and are still easy to eat. The downside: there’s probably more ice cream than you really need, but it’s definitely worth it. They accept card payments, and there are little boxes available. They also offer different pie shots, and you can even buy the cookies themselves.

This charming little spot is tucked away on a side street in downtown St. Augustine. They offer gluten-free and vegan options, with a great variety of flavors to choose from. The service was very friendly. The gluten-free sandwich had a firmer texture, making it a bit challenging to bite into, but it was flavorful. We definitely plan to return!

I visited this place with some friends at night. I found the ice cream sandwiches to be a bit inconsistent. I absolutely loved the salted caramel brownie, although it was a tad too big for my small mouth! My friend ordered what I believe was the hazelnut chocolate, but I didn't think it measured up, which was a bit disappointing.