Martolli's Authentic Hand-tossed Pizza In Sisters

The staff were really nice and had the food ready for pickup on time for when I requested pickup online. But the pizzas and bread were both really dry. One pizza was burned on the bottom. Could have just been a fluke, and it seemed like a good place otherwise so still worth considering for takeout pizza.

The staff was lovely, very kind and wanted to ensure we had everything we need to take out. The pizza itself was unflavored…I bought the cheese and the Ponderosa, both dry and had zero flavor. I didn’t know that possible with a pizza with so much. The sauce is non existence. I was more excited from a .99 cent party pizza pepperoni. After 75.00 disappointed. Such a blow for a weekend away.

Alex was Awesome she made us feel at home and our pizza was so delicious we will definitely be back for more thank you!!!

Ordered a slice of pep to have on the go while we were walking around town. It was heated up quickly, the crust was nice a crisp, flavor was good, perfect amount of sauce (I like light sauce). Pretty decent slice and almost went back for another but we ran out of time. Docking stars because the staff seemed annoyed to be there, the bathroom was so gross and needs a solid deep clean, and the sign on the pop machine is just off putting.

This place is exactly what it says it is just good, large portioned, takeout pizzas at a good price that will feed plenty of people. It’s nothing super fancy, dine in area is small, outdoor seating is nice, but these guys just do an awesome job.