Sewickley Cafe

Located in the Sewickley Hotel. This country themed tavern is absolutely charming! It was a little more crowded than I prefer but the food was phenomenal! I can't tell you the last time I had such a fantastic meal! We ordered the lamb lollipops appetizer and it came with fries and coleslaw! Best lamb I've ever had! The beet salad, chicken pailliard, and linguini were all amazing! I HIGHLY recommend! I can't wait to go back!

Everything we ordered was incredible. For starters we ordered the mixed olives and fried mozzarella, which wasn’t your standard mozz stick at a bar, this was fresh mozz slabs breaded and fried. Super unique and perfect. The chicken sandwich was one of the best we’ve ever had. The fries were thick cut but still super crispy on the outside and nice and creamy inside. The Mahi was incredible as well. Perfectly cooked fish with a jerk rub served with a sweet and spicy mango salsa. Cocktails were really unique and delicious as well. This place is the definition of a gem.

The food and wine were great and the server was fantastic.

UPDATE: SEWICKLEY TAVERN IS CLOSING. JULY 24th IS THEIR LAST DAY and honestly it’s the biggest loss in Sewickley. The food and staff have continuously been incredible. There’s nothing else that compares to the food and ambiance. I hope the owner realizes the gem she has here and reopens quickly when more staff becomes available.Female owned, managed by a genius, the chef is a food god. Fourth time in two months here. This is a destination and a (if you can) go to restaurant. You won’t be disappointed by any dish, but I HIGHLY suggest the seared tuna shishito peppers and the Cesar salad. The chicken sandwich is also . Carmen is a fantastic human. Hope she’s your server regardless your night will be a memorable, lovely experience.

Had our first in-person restaurant meal here recently and we were impressed with the food, service and decor. So glad to see this in Sewickley. A good replacement for the lamented Cocothe.