Seaford Bagels

Delicious bagels and amazing sandwiches. I highly recommend this place—it's a must-visit!

I watched the staff cook my sandwich while filming a video (probably for TikTok), and then they called my name. After leaving, I realized that my sandwich was incorrect; it was missing the bacon for my bacon, egg, and cheese. I had to return to the counter, and the woman who had been cooking wouldn’t even turn to face me as she said, “I’m listening.” She then told her coworker she would just add bacon to it. I asked if they could remake the sandwich since it had gotten cold while I was waiting. This request seemed to further irritate her. I overheard her discussing customers and their complaints, and I couldn’t help but think that if she had focused more on making the orders correctly instead of filming, this mistake could have been avoided. I didn’t even bother asking for a new iced coffee because it had gotten watered down from the waiting and returning. Overall, the sandwich was mediocre; the bagel was unremarkable, and the customer service was truly disappointing. Mistakes can happen, but the way they were handled and the attitudes of the staff will deter me from returning. The girl who took my order was pleasant and recorded it correctly, so I don’t blame her for the mix-up.

Behind the counter, you see a team of friendly staff members diligently working to fulfill customers' orders. The display case showcases a wide variety of bagels, each one perfectly baked to a golden-brown crust. You can spot classic flavors like plain, sesame, and everything, along with an assortment of specialty options like cinnamon raisin, blueberry, and multigrain.The menu board offers an array of bagel sandwich options, making it difficult to choose just one. From classic combinations like lox and cream cheese to more adventurous options like turkey and avocado, there's something to satisfy every craving. You notice that they also offer a range of spreads, such as flavored cream cheeses, hummus, and butter, to complement your bagel of choice.The bakery also caters to those with dietary preferences or restrictions, as you notice a selection of gluten-free and vegan bagels. This inclusive approach ensures that everyone can enjoy the deliciousness Seaford Bagels has to offer.

Pretty good bagels. My favorite so far is the Everything Bagel, I really can't complain. I notice over the years they changed the bagels like to taste healthier but I think they are still good anyway.Thank you!

Bagel shops on the south shore of Long Island are incredibly popular for breakfast, and I've been visiting this spot for over a decade when I come to see my son in Seaford. Arriving early enhances the experience because it’s less crowded, allowing for better attention to my order. The breakfast sandwiches and bagels here are among the best, and there’s usually decent parking, although weekends can get busy. I have occasionally received incorrect orders or items that were missing, especially during peak times with employees who seem distracted by the noise or crowd. However, when I go early enough to avoid the rush and my order is perfect, the breakfast experience is outstanding. This is especially true if you don’t visit Long Island often and are eager to enjoy a delicious bagel or egg sandwich.