Castaways Seafood And Grille - Seabrook

Not Castaways any more. It changed owners and is call ERNIE'S . Has mostly seafood. On the noisy side but food was good. Nice outside seating area..was not open when we were there due to weather. Has a firepit and Deck bar. Awesome views.

My husband, stepson, and I came to Rye Beach to celebrate my birthday. I'm happy we started on the beach because had my dining experience here been my first stop I would have gone home with a ruined birthday.I don't know what was more disgusting, the food or the elderly GM clearly flirting with his underage waitresses. The menu doesn't accurately describe what the food really is. You end up paying unreasonable prices for frozen processed food. We will never come here again.

View from deck was beautiful. Seafood Alfredo was plentiful in seafood and very tasty. Lobster pie was overcooked. Baked haddock was sub par. Fried haddock breading was mushy and the portion was the size of a deck of cards. ****** Marys were terrible. Definitely not worth visiting due to the portion sizes and the very poor quality of the meals for the price.

LAME! Went with a party of 5 and had quite the experience. It was a Tuesday night, barely anyone there. We ordered a 40 dollar of wine and was brought two visibly dirty glasses. We had to scrape off whatever white bits were caked on the inside. When we asked for clean glasses she brought back two DIRTIER glasses and left the first pair on the table.Apps: tasteless, thin onion rings and a pound and a half oh please! of steamers.Once we received the food we had to ask for silverware.Meal 1: Grilled salmon. It tasted good but the whole plate was cold.. The potatoes were clearly microwaved and tasted pretty yucky. Toss on a few pieces of squash and you got yourself a 30 dollar plate lolMeal 2: Tuna burger was fine. Was given the wrong side which was a stale plate of mashed potatoes meant for someone else at the table.Meal 3: side of mashed potatoes. Pretty terrible tasting and only vaguely resembled mashed potatoes.Meal 4: Seafood Alfredo: not worth the price $40 rubbery shrimp and the mussels weren 't even touched. They looked really bad.Meal 5: steak tips, ordered medium rare came WELL done. It was all really underwhelming and the experience was hilariously bad. The view was nice though!They should train their staff and I 'm sure things would turn around but it felt like everything was really sad.

Pretty good fish, pretty bad burgers. But let 's face it, if you go to a place on the seacoast called Castaways and you order a burger, you 're rolling the dice. The service was inviting and attentive, but of course we got there as soon as they opened, so it could be different during the rush. The drinks menu was pretty extensive, and my wife got a frozen mango margarita, which she described as yummy . Two of us got the fried haddock, which was delicious. Two of us, however, got cheeseburgers, which weren 't. One of the burgers was the charred memory of beef, and both came with homemade potato chips which were left largely untouched. It 's a tad overpriced $140 for four lunches and two cocktails, including tip), but it 's the seacoast, so some tourist trap markup is to be expected and not really worth complaining about. We 'll go back, but next time, we 'll all get seafood.