Nickelby's - SEA ISLE CITY

The sandwiches themselves were good—not the best bagel I've ever had, but certainly not the worst. We considered trying the brioche bun instead, but overall, it did the job and provided tasty nourishment. I would rate the sandwich a 4 out of 5, but the counterman's attitude earns a 2, resulting in an average rating of 3 stars.

I had an incredible first visit a few years ago—the food, service, everything was top-notch. On my second visit, while the food was still good, the service had declined. However, today’s experience was quite disappointing. Everyone working there seemed unhappy, and the cashier lacked any customer service skills. I ordered the smoked salmon on a bagel, but I ended up tossing it when I got home because the bagel was so hard that I couldn't even bite into it. The cream cheese and capers were just piled in the middle instead of being spread out. My cold brew coffee was mostly ice, and the cheese danish left much to be desired.

I’ve had a couple of good breakfasts at Nickelby’s- this round we both got pork roll breakfast sandwiches- mine on brioche and his on an everything bagel. The pork roll was sliced thick and it was so good on the sandwich! The bagel also got a thumbs up. The multiple varieties of crumb cakes were catching my eye but I didn’t grab any…this time.

This was my first time here. It is walking distance from my rental so it was very convenient to walk here for coffee every morning. The food is very good and the baked items looked delicious. There are Philly pretzels here so this was a plus for me. There is plenty of outdoor seating.

Excellent experience!!! Blonde girl working at register was SO GREAT!! Gave us recommendations not only for delicious food (I got the porkroll breakfast sandwich ? , but for fun activities around Sea Isle.... That's customer service!!!!! I will most definitely be back.