The Penny Ice Creamery - Santa Cruz

Best ice cream ever. I would recommend to anyone go here only for ice cream.

My favorite ice cream! I love the toasted marshmallow fluff on everything, more decadence please! The browned butter spiced pecan is a can't miss flavor and I love that ice creams are different than the usual grocery store-type finds. Everything is delicious and it's awesome to know things are locally sourced, when possible, and I'm supporting a local business.

The toasted marshmallow fluff is the main reason we came here, but I found the ice cream to be just okay. Flavors are limited which I don't mind, but the ice cream itself wasn't very creamy and the texture was very soft and melty. None of the flavors especially stood out and I tried three. Expensive too, but staff are very nice and the long line went by quickly.

I visited this place, i tried the vanilla and dark chocolate i liked it very much.Who ever likes vanilla flavour then you must try here. They offer different other flavours based on the seasonal fruits.The shop is small and seating is less so don't worry about the space enjoy the lovely icecream.???

I got the vanilla and butterscotch taffy.What I liked most was that as the ice cream melted in my mouth, it didn’t leave a greasy feeling behind. And yet it felt rich and creamy. A tad too sweet and there were some huge chunks of taffy that took some effort to break up but otherwise this ice cream was a delight!— @eddythefoodcritic