Sibby's Cupcakery - San Mateo

Love this place. Super creative with decorations and always keeps designs fresh. The regular cupcakes are a perfect size IMO and minis are delightful. If just stopping by, get there early for best selection. They don’t always have time to update what’s in stock on the sign outside so be prepared with backup options. Ex. Check website or photos so you know the names ahead.

These cupcakes were super yummy and some of the best cupcakes I’ve ever tasted. I basically consider myself a professional cupcake connoisseur I’ve eaten cupcakes all around this country lol! I loved the mocha, chewy chocolate, strawberry lemonade, and carrot cake. Do call at least a day ahead to order. If you show up on the day of, you can only buy excess cupcakes from someone else’s order. I took one star off because showing up to buy cupcakes was a confusing customer experience. The store didn’t even have an accurate list of which cupcakes are available at the moment and they only have a small selection of flavors.

I stop by every time I am around San Mateo. Today I notice the frosting of the cupcake was extra sweet. I don’t know if you changed the ingredients or the recipe. I try strawberry cream, piña colada and dulce de leche. The cake itself was great but the frosting was extremely sweet and it was not like that before. Thats the reason I gave 4 instead of 5 starts.

One of the best, if not the best, cupcakes I have tasted. I could hardly wait to try one. Love the buttercream frosting. It is buttery, creamy and not overly sweet. Perfection Since my last review, I had cupcakes from here for a special girl turning 3years old. She is really into Princess Sophia and Sibby's made the most wonderful and beautifully decorated cupcakes. Love this place.

Super friendly staff. Wonderful cupcakes. Flavorful and moist. So very cute!!! Love the birthday theme customized to my daughter's favorite color, free of charge. Usually have to preorder but usually they have some available for purchase too.