Selma's Chicago Pizzeria Tap Room San Juan

The food was excellent. Although the staff at the front were busy seating customers, the manager took the time to come over, seat us, answer all our questions, and take our order. He was fantastic, and it was clear that he is a very engaged leader. Many companies would benefit from having someone like him at the helm.

Gotta rave about this restaurant. I have been trying to find good Chicago style deep dish pizza in California for 23 years and found it here, quite by accident. My Wife and I both are originally from Chicago, and we are very familiar with what makes a good, no, great deep dish pizza. This place got it right! We split a small size, with only Italian sausage (good quality sausage too), we started off with the regular size Italian chopped salad. This was plenty of food for us both and probably too much for a couple of average eaters. The staff was courteous and helpful, very professional. The restaurant was clean and very pleasant, with windows open to the sidewalk and an outdoor patio. There is a full bar which features a happy hour menu. The restrooms were well maintained, clean and fully stocked. Service was quick. The price for all this was not bad either! We had two iced teas as well, and the bill, with tax, came out to just $36.96! About what you would pay for a couple of burgers in a casual dining restaurant. All in all, I, we highly recommend this restaurant and will be coming back again.

We're big Selma's fans. Chill pizza joint with good bar food, salads, sandwiches and options to accommodate all diets such as vegan, gluten free and keto. Parking is usually pretty easy in the structure around the corner, but you may have to park on the roof. Good options for families and big parties. Nice outdoor dining options, rotating taps and sports always playing. Servers are always pleasant. Pizza can be expensive because of the quality ingredients and crust options. Accepts all credit cards. If you find this post helpful please like!

My wife and I visited this restaurant for the third time and thoroughly enjoyed the food, service, and atmosphere. It was a lovely day, so we opted to sit outside on the beautiful terrace, complete with a fireplace. Since it was Wine Wednesday, we savored a delicious bottle of Pinot Grigio alongside the Fetalicious salad, their homemade sourdough rolls, and an authentic Chicago cheese pizza. For dessert, we indulged in the Mothership, which featured a warm chocolate chip cookie topped with two scoops of vanilla ice cream. I highly recommend it, especially if you’re feeling full! Our server, Tatum, did an excellent job and was very attentive to our needs. The manager also checked in on us several times to ensure we had everything we needed. In summary, we enjoyed great food, a wonderful atmosphere, attentive service, and an excellent location. We can’t wait for our next visit!

Selma's Chicago Pizzeria is an outstanding restaurant with several locations in the area. One location requires paid parking, while the others offer free parking options. The staff are fantastic, and the menu is extensive with a wonderful selection of beers. It's a great place to bring your whole family and enjoy a meal together. They also show sports on the TVs in the bar area. If you're interested, there are private event rooms available as well. One of the owners is a family man, which I really appreciate. Overall, it's a highly recommended spot!