Atlantic Grill - Rye

Atlantic Grill is a jewel! Excellent kitchen, excellent service! 5 of us appeared on a busy Sunday, no tables on the line. In no time has the staff set up a table on the terrace. Within minutes we explore the menu and enjoy our cocktails. Fresh is the word! I've been a patron for years and it just keeps me back! You will enjoy your time here!

The food used good ingredients, was perfectly cooked, but it was remarkably under-seasoned and price at about $50 per person for dinner with apps. After I loved Thistle Pig, I know that Chef Ben (and almost always) can do better. I suspect that lack of personnel in the kitchen interferes with performance. It was still a good meal, but not memorable, and we needed to reach almost everything from the kitchen to the great flavors we expected.

Enjoy a nice lunch on a rainy Sunday in the Atlantic Grill. Able to make reservations was in an area directly from a beautiful gas fireplace. Tables are socially distant. Our waiter was very attentive. The food was great. Beer batterfish was crispy and tender, served with crispy frits. Hubby got Caesar salad with celebrities from this world. Clam Chowder was good too. Oh, I almost forgot! Yummy **** Marys. Guests can enjoy a return in summer for the outdoor seats.

For the first time a few months ago here and the food was delicious! The restaurant was so sweet and our waitress was friendly. My only complaint is that her mule for the Moscow mule was not good in the least. It was so watered that it tasted like ginger water without lime or carbonate.

Birthday snacking with one of my best gal pals, we decided to try Atlantic Grill as I'd been eyeing it on my trips to the beach and had been meaning to try. The shrimp cocktail was INCREDIBLE, but definitely left you wanting more. Maybe the look they're going for, but this girl wants more than 3 shrimp