Sergio's - Riverhead

Always happy and full with this pizza whether we pick up or get delivery. Delivery is always fast and the pizza is always hot! The crust is delightful. The staff is friendly. And they are always consistent!

I grew up with Sergio's and Carlo's in riverhead. I moved away nearly 30 years ago and everything I come home I stop in and grab a couple slices and garlic knots. The people working there are great, and the pizza and knots never disappoint! Love me Sergio's! Now if they'd open a spot in Maine I'd be in heaven!

Ordered Veal Cutlet Parm meal with Garlic Knots and a side salad. Veal was so tender you can cut it with a fork. Sauce was awesome! One meal split between both my wife and I and it was MORE than enough. We've been ordering from Sergio's for almost 5 years. You want home-cooked? Order here! You want CHEAP? Order Dominos or Pizza Hut! This is REAL Italian food!!

Been ordering here for a while food is good people are nice but I always ask them to make my pies thin and crispy/well done. I don’t like floppy crust. They never get it right. It’s always under cooked. I’m tired of asking them to make it well done. Time to find a new place. Sorry but how hard is it to make a crust well done!!

Everything is cool the Spanish gentleman was helping me out until that lady she didn't even ask me what is my order not even saying thank you she actually just leaving on the table and I have to grab it myself it's not about the Stars it's about how to serve the people the lady was waiting for her order she looks at me and I told her I will never come back here again unless she is not here anymore