Kinchley's Tavern - Ramsey

Kinchleys serves the best thin crust pizza in the area! We absolutely love it!

The interior decoration feels like a throwback to a different era, and they only accept cash, which is a drawback for me. While many others rave about their pizza, I wasn't particularly impressed with the place. Additionally, the host who greets you (a man) isn't very welcoming. I would prefer to dine elsewhere.

The best pizza in the world! We travel 10 hours just to get to Kinchleys! I’ve loved it since I was 12 and living in West Milford, and now we drive all the way from Smith Mountain Lake.

My son and I dined there for the first time yesterday, and we could tell the food would be delicious since it was packed during Saturday lunch. My son ordered a sausage sandwich, and we shared a garlic cake. While he enjoyed the sandwich, we both agreed that the pizza was the standout. Coming from the Bronx, I know a great pizza when I taste one! We don’t live close by, but you can be sure we’ll be back for more!

This is a clean, friendly local pizza place that serves up some incredible cakes. It's definitely a must-visit! Just remember that they only accept cash, and it tends to be quite busy.