Costella's - Puyallup

The food was great and the service was decent. The tables were spaced well and made the experience comfortable.

We were truly excited to have a new restaurant to go to in Puyallup but after going we were totally disappointed. Besides the frirndly staff, there was nothing really good about this place. The food was blah, the wine list was terrible and chouces of beer were terrible. Try getting a decent chef and manager and maybe we will try it again. I had the chopped salad which was not good, the dressing should be creamy Italian, its not. The olive oil and balsamic was terrible!!! The pesto gnocchi tasted like a freezer brand I bought. This place will not last a year unless they step it up, and I mean step it up Alot!!!

Was not able to give correct reaction because the restaurant was closed due to maintenance on oct 3 was not able to give correct response so these ratings do not reflect because was not able to eat there

We were so disappointed! This place seemed to have good reviews, so we decided to give it an attempt. Staff are all incredibly friendly and fun so my low rating is for the food. The lasagna we served was so bland! No herbs, garlic or sausage... it had absolutely no taste! When I talked to our server about it and described the Lasagna who received Rave reviews, she said: “Oh, that was three chefs! We let every new cook turn on our menu.” Even the bruschetta starter was tasteless... something you don't often experience in an Italian restaurant. So be careful when you look at the reviews to make sure they are up to date.

A very delightful experience. The food was amazing!