Nico's Pizza - Provo

Went and tried a different pizzeria today in Provo. I went to Nicotalia Pizzeria tonight. It's a Boston style pizzeria. This place looks like they have a great selection of food to order. I ordered a stromboli with pepperoni, sausage, salami, and mushrooms, buffalo wings, and their medium 12 Nico's Special pizza. Super nice manager named Ben there tonight and it seemed like he was in a great mood and giving customers and myself a free soda cup. Very nice gesture. I was excited for the food as I sat waiting for mine and saw the dine in customers enjoying their dinner. Unfortunately, I was a bit disappointed with the quality tonight. My stromboli and pizza could have both stayed in the oven for maybe a few more minutes. It was still a bit doughy and raw-ish for both. The stromboli tasted great after I threw it in the oven for a few minutes. I can definitely see myself ordering this more often. Lots of flavor in every bite. The buffalo wings were very sweet and no kick at all. Maybe it is just their style. It was alright, just a bit sweet for my taste. The Nico's Special pizza looks simple, esthetically pleasing, and decent in flavor after I threw it in the oven for a few minutes. I think a thinner crust is their style which I didn't mind. They didn't have to rush my order tonight because it felt like the manager didn't want me to wait too long for my order. I'll have to give it some time before I come back and try it again and hope for a better experience with my food. #thisishowichow @nicospizzaprovo

Wow! Amazing service, delicious food, and at a great price! Their Lewinsky pizza (secret menu item) is incredible. It was so delicious I didn't manage to snag a photo before it was gone. But I remember chicken, bacon, pepperoni, buffalo sauce, BBQ sauce and jalapeno peppers. Not too spicy. Just the right amount of kick. Their house dressing is incredible. Put it on everything! Bread sticks and cheese sticks are fantastic. Perfect amount of crust for pizza. Not too thin or greasy. First trip of what I forsee being MANY. Plus the owner and employees provided amazing service. We spoke to several different employees while we were there and every one of them were incredibly personable and helpful. The owner even offered us some basketball tickets!

Great service! Our checkout was super helpful and friendly. We tried the bbq chicken pizza and really enjoyed the crust. It was the perfect consistency. The pricing is a bit more, but the pizza dough is very different from what you would get on a chain pizza joint. Overall, I would visit again, but only with a deal or voucher, because the price was slightly higher than my preference.

Really good pizza here. The staff is friendly and the range of TVs is a great time to relax. The slice of the day is a great option and the bread sticks with Alfredo sauce are both really good. I highly recommend the bunker hill or BBQ chicken pizza. Quality and good pizza place!

Wow, this place is the best pizza place I visited in Utah! We ordered CMA ( chicken alfredo) and Nikos special pizza both small size. They both tasted fantastic and I really like the thickness of their dough and how to crack their crust. I can usually taste wheat when I eat pizza, but I didn't taste with Nico's pizza. They also have their special sauce and it tastes like Ranch Honey Senf Doritos 39 other ingredients. It is a lot of taste at once and they mix super well together I was really surprised how good their sauce was! You should try them. If you ask for the sauce, the cashier will give it to you. They also have parmesian cheese and red pepper flakes and these are self-service. The place is spacious and I like the interior design. They have awards hanging with funny frames and the place is really clean and clean. I will definitely come back to try more flavors and will spread the word to my friends about this fantastic restaurant. Above all, their price is good. Although I got a small size, I was full after completion.