I Love Ny Pizza - Porters Neck

Always been my favorite Wilmington pizza spot, up until today. Something has gone wrong either ingredients are being swapped out for less expensive cheaper versions or people aren't putting the pieces together correctly I ordered two slices one of them came extremely burnt so they threw a cold piece in there for free. Margarita and barbecue chicken, never have I had such horrible Pizza especially from here. The cheese is definitely different, generic, not tasty at all. Hardly any chicken, BBQ sauce was off. I hate to leave these comments because this is always been a treat to me to get pizza from here. Whatever y'all have changed you need to change it back

Bar none the best pie in Wilmington. Sliced sausage, not crumbled. The only way.

I always love getting pizza here when I come to visit so many pizza slices options and friendly customer service

My absolute favorite pizza on the Earth. I found out about this place when I was looking to move to Wilmington, NC from Fayetteville, NC in 2006. When I got there, I asked for a slice of Rio Rancho because it looked different. When I got it, I felt like I was getting the pizza I saw when I 5 years old watching TMNT for the first time and they got their pizza delivered and started tearing into it lol. No matter how silly that sounds, that's how good this pizza is. Perfect! It is my favorite pizza on the planet. Whenever anyone i talk to brings up pizza I always say go to I Love NY Pizza, Wilmington, NC! I've never ordered anything but a Rio Rancho pizza from this place since. I've ordered slices of course. But the Rio Rancho holds a special place in my heart. And, although I haven't seen the older gentleman I saw cooking pizza's for year's... in year's. They've kept up the same exact taste and service which usually isn't the case for most restaurants. I've made it back to Wilmington literally just for this pizza a couple of time's a year. When I either lived 2 hrs away or 8 1/2 hrs away. When i lived 2 hrs away i would pack my kids up on the weekend just to go get a pizza from this place so they love it too. So.... I moved to TN a few year's ago after living in Wilmington for a while and moving back to Fayetteville and even though I can't make it back as many time's as I wish I could. I make sure to go there 2 time's every time I come within 2 hrs of this pizza place and drive to get my favorite pizza ever. Literally, the best pizza you will ever have. Especially if you order your own Extra Large. I got an XL Rio Rancho today 7- 2-24 and I put it in ziplock bags to take with me back to TN lol. I'll be going to Wilmington again Friday just to get another Rio Rancho to pack up and take back to TN!!! Thank you for continuing to keep up the quality and prices I've had for the last almost 20 year's!!!

Such a fun walk up window my group and I ended up going twice in one day! Will be going back. Pizza was great very flavorful and not too greasy at all! They were open late which was nice after going to the bar