Twilight Cafe Pj - PORT JEFFERSON

This is a fantastic little spot! The staff was incredibly helpful. Make sure to sample a drink before making a purchase. They offer a variety of flavored oils and vinegars in different sizes. You can also buy bottles as party gifts, complete with custom pictures and lettering.

I and the family visited here on Friday before we went to Joey's Z next door. The amount of different kinds of olive oil is amazing! Huge selection, and the place feels very cozy. I have the Scorpion Hot Sauce from here, it is very hot and very tasteful. I always use it. Remember to come back to the ferry and more of this haha!

On my second visit, I picked up the labels and also bought a gift certificate because I knew my friend wanted to come in and try the olives himself. Today was my third trip, and once again, we were greeted with friendly smiles. We sampled a wide variety of olives and spent quite some time there. We ended up purchasing some fig balsamic vinegar, jalapeño white balsamic vinegar, and Tuscan olive oil, along with a few tasting dishes. We’re so excited to try everything, and once we do, I have no doubt we'll be back for more. This place is perfect for gifts, wedding and baby showers, or just to treat yourself. There are countless reasons to visit!

The Amazing Olive is truly exceptional! The owner, Candy, was knowledgeable, attentive, and incredibly helpful in creating custom gifts for me. She put together three impeccable baskets and included the alcohol I requested as an addition. Everything was beautiful! I can't recommend this place highly enough!

Staff is super friendly and knowledgeable. Great products as well. They even have a loyalty program which helps bc it is a bit pricey.