Pappaceno's Pizza - Orchard Park

Quick service and delicious pizza and wings! A fantastic place to stop for a Bills game.

I ordered a double serving of wings with extra blue cheese. The person who took my order told me my food would arrive in 45 minutes. However, almost half an hour later, it still hadn’t arrived. I called to check, and was told it would be there in just a minute. Another half hour went by, and when I called again, they claimed the order would be delivered in 5 minutes. After a lengthy 2-hour wait, my order finally arrived. It turns out the wings weren’t even cooked when they mentioned those 5 minutes! The customer service from the guy on the phone was lacking, to say the least. While the wings were tasty and they did include the extra blue cheese I paid for, overall, it was a frustrating experience and I wouldn’t recommend this place.

Pappaciano's is undoubtedly the best pizza place in the city, offering delicious food at excellent prices. Their lunch specials are perfect for a midday meal, and you can always rely on prompt delivery.

Ordered a simple cheese pizza with a well cooked crust. I got a pepperoni pizza with a barely cooked crust. I love the sauce and usually the crust from here which is why I try it from time to time. I live within walking distance but rarely come because of the inconsistency. I generally pay far more from a place further away for the consistency.

My wife and I just ordered a white pizza, stuffed hot peppers and a steak spinach sub. Everything was absolutely delicious. My wife said its the best steak sub she has had from anywhere. Pappacenos is the most consistent pizzeria in town.