Nancy's Pizza - O'Fallon

I had an amazing experience at this restaurant tonight. I ordered a medium stuffed pizza loaded with meat, and I could only finish two slices because it was so filling. My wife absolutely loved it as well! The staff were incredibly friendly and even apologized for my slight wait, which was just two minutes longer than they had estimated. Their Chicago-style pizza is by far the best I've had in the area. We will definitely be ordering from them again!

No other pizza in the St. Louis area comes close to this one! The deep dish is absolutely heavenly, but I also adore the thin crust for a lighter choice—it’s just as delightful.

My son and I recently tried the stuffed deep dish 'A Lot 'A Meat' pizza for the first time, and we were thoroughly impressed. We ordered it for delivery, and it arrived hot and fresh. We both agree that this is, without a doubt, the best pizza we've had in St. Charles County, and we will certainly be ordering from Nancy's again. I hope this review encourages others to support this local business, as O'Fallon, MO really needs more quality food options! The crust was perfectly crispy, and the deep dish was loaded with cheese. As soon as I brought the pizza inside, my son commented on how amazing it smelled—something we've never experienced with places like Domino's or Papa John's!

On a whim, we decided to try Nancy's Pizza, and now we can't imagine eating anywhere else. We ordered a cheese-stuffed deep-dish pizza, and it was incredible—hot, gooey cheese that reminded me of the best deep dish I’ve had since childhood. We’ll definitely be recommending Nancy's to all our family and friends!

This was an excellent pizza with well-balanced flavors. I enjoy this style of deep dish from time to time, and Nancy's really hit the mark! It's the best deep dish I've had in the area. I also appreciate the consistency of the pizza; it tastes the same every time. The garlic cheese bread is nice, but not extraordinary. If you're looking for a delicious deep dish with a great balance of tomato, cheese, and your choice of toppings, definitely give this place a try!