Pepperoni Grill At The Beach

I was not impressed. Despite the good ratings, the food was mediocre. My husband ordered pizza and I got the eggplant, both were just average. The garlic knots, which were complimentary, were terrible - undercooked and cold. The outdoor dining area was nice, but it would have been better if there was something to see or do.

Hands down the best pizza on the island! And even had New York company, who are particularly about their pizza, exclaim how excellent it is too.

The use of fresh ingredients and handmade dough results in a superbly fantastic pizza!! It's absolutely delicious! It's recommended to order takeout unless the weather is nice to dine outdoors.

Very good pizza. I'll definitely stop again when I'm in the area. Everyone was super friendly and helpful.

Pizza is very good, sauce is flavorful and cheese is on par with any good established pizza joint. Garden Stromboli was insanely watery, most likely because of the tomatoes, which in the end the chef should know doesn’t make this dish work. Yet the Stromboli was still decent. Pass on the garlic knots, subpar compared to other places. Friendly staff and easy to get to location! Solid 4 star joint!