Bagel Bob's - New York City

Their everything bagel is the best in NYC! Finally, a true gem!

The Nova Scotia Salmon Sandwich is delicious, and the dozen bagels I ordered arrived still warm, which was fantastic!

The onion bagels are fantastic! I believe this is the best bagel shop in New York City!

They have whole wheat sesame, my favorite! The bagels here are soft with just a little chew. They don’t need toasted IMO. I got the scallion tofu and my partner got the veggie tofu shmear. Both were good but I think I’d get the veggie next time. It had lots of flavor. Might be my favorite NY bagel so far.

I absolutely loved my bagel from this bagel shop. I was fortunate to get an everything bagel one minute after it finished cooking, which meant it was hot and extra delicious! There were a number of tofu cream cheese options available, vegetable and scallion are my go-to. One item to note, is the cream cheese tastes different and more delicious at this bagel shop than others I have been to in New York. I personally think this is a better bagel option in NYC given the bagel flavor/texture and delicious cream cheese options. I almost skipped it because of the lower rating due to someone giving BB a 2* rating, but so glad I went anyway. It was the best bagel of this trip. Please not BB is also listed as a “bagel of note” on the bagel maps, which meant I had to try it: [hidden link] Updated from previous review on 2023-06-29